Crumbl Cookies review #101 - Martha Stewart Coconut Cake and Pumpkin Sheet Cake

Crumbl Cookies review #101 - Martha Stewart Coconut Cake and Pumpkin Sheet Cake, visited November 3, 2025

Still trying to catch up on my Crumbl reviews. This'll be a short one. Crumbl made a big deal of this collab with Martha Stewart. I didn't pay much attention other than to see her logo over the dessert descriptions. I only got 2 which were all I wanted to try from the options: the coconut cake and the pumpkin sheet cake.

I went on a Monday which I normally try not to do as I like to give the Crumbl employees a few days to perfect that week's offerings. As you can see from the first picture, whoever piped the frosting on the coconut cake hadn't quite nailed it. But, I don't sweat that stuff so it wasn't a big deal. The cake was good, nice and fluffy. I would've liked more coconut in the cake however but that's me as a coconut lover.

I don't know that I'd get this again but at least the surcharge wasn't too crazy: $4.69 regular cookie price + $0.49 surcharge = $5.18.

The Pumpkin Sheet Cake was also good but in all honesty, I couldn't tell you the difference between this and the Pumpkin Cake from a couple weeks ago. Except this pumpkin sheet cake had a massive amount of frosting vs the pumpkin cake had a nice thin glaze. Good in terms of taste but thumbs down on that much frosting. This was the same price as the Coconut Cake: $4.69 regular cookie price + $0.49 surcharge = $5.18.